Categories
cognitive science Discourse Meta

Pile of Provisional Positions (PPP), Part 1, The PPP

Greetings, Friendlies! I harbor some baseless supposition (BS?) that classical dhamma education unfolds via a structure honed over, perhaps, several thousand years? Theories and practices presented in an order and at a pace curated and refined for generations. Practical. Reproducible. Safe. I have not been the beneficiary (or victim) of such a system; coming up […]

Categories
Discourse Practice Teaching

Nothing Good Or Bad But Tribalism Makes it So

If I consider you as inside my tribe, I am naturally “good” to you. I will take care of you; I may even risk my life to save you or that which you love.

If I consider you outside my tribe, look out.

Categories
Discourse Meta

Avijjā as Polestar

What I see as the fundamental problem, and what I am most interested in working on, is that we humans do not understand the kind of beings we are.

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

Avijjā as Mis-understanding

Greetings, Friendlies. :) For your consideration: what about translating Avijjā as “Mis-understanding”? “Ignorance” seems a little pejorative, “confusion” a little apathetic. Mis-understanding may sound odd at first, but in dhamma circles we do something similar when we speak of dis-ease. We are not speaking of illness, we are speaking of _not being at ease_. In […]

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

¿Chemotaxis as a Vedanā Precursor? Part 2, So What?

Previously we proposed that chemotaxis may be a precursor of vedanā and that holding this view (lightly) may contribute to a more embedded/interconnected understanding of human-beingness in the spectrum of life. This time I’d like to play with the idea that infusing an understanding of vedanā with a sense of taxis/movement can more coherently embed […]

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

¿Chemotaxis as a Vedanā Precursor? Part 1, What?

Articulating an idea in the vedanā discussion: Sometimes dharma teachers note that a precursor of vedanā may be observed in organisms as simple as single-celled bacteria. These organisms move towards food (that which is beneficial) and away from toxins (that which is harmful). The term for this movement is “chemotaxis”. “Chemo” from the Greek “khemeia”, […]

Categories
Discourse Meta Scholarship

“Valence” as an English Translation of “Vedanā”

Perhaps. Some dharma teachers claim there is no English equivalent for the Pāli “vedanā” . Although I do not know a word in common usage, there has been a word used in psychology since the 1930s, “valence”, that I think will do the job very well. [1] In (the HIGHLY recommended) How Emotions Are Made, […]

Categories
Discourse Meta

Making Time

“if we want to focus our minds on serious and difficult things, we may at points have to take some radical steps – and to do things that will strike some people as odd and or even unwarranted.” ~Alain de Botton, How to Think More Effectively A few years ago I wrote about Gregg McKeowen’s […]

Categories
Discourse

Thoughts on Determinism / Free Will

Chatting with a friend about Existentialism, Buddhist Ethics, Determinism, Free Will (because that’s the kind of nerds we are). Today’s position on determinism / free will: I come from a strongly evolutionary perspective, and a strongly materialist perspective. Should be logically hemmed into determinism. I also study ethics and attempt to cultivate (aka, re-wire my […]

Categories
cognitive science Discourse Scholarship

Viññāṇa, CogSci Support for “Consciousness Of”

Perhaps. Regarding Viññāṇa, I first heard the phrasing “Consciousness Of” from John Peacock’s “Buddhism Before the Theravada” series (Part 5, 53:45): “…consciousness is always a consciousness of…” something. That is, Gotama spoke of consciousness always having an object. (MN 38) “Consciousness is reckoned according to the very same condition dependent upon which it arises. Consciousness that […]

Categories
Discourse

Playful Dhamma

Dear Friendlies, Greetings! Writing in a rush, my fingers tangling in the keyboard. Please excuse if incoherent; excited. I think I’ve understood something (again), and wondering if any of you have advice in this direction. An aspect of my life that is lacking in cultivation is the eleventh parami. Humor. Levity. Actually I think the best […]

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

Metta Sutta, A Translation Proposal

In the Metta Sutta (Snp 1.8 and Khp 9) there is a line Gil Fronsdal translates “As a mother would risk her own life to protect her child, her only child”. The Pāli here translated as child is “putta”. John Peacock has said that this more accurately translates to “son” (see 1:11:22). My knowledge of Pāli […]

Categories
DharmaPhD Discourse

Dukkha. Also, Levity.

Playing around with my smart phone and found you can make a lock screen out of just emojis. So… This is my kind of dhamma. Sure, dukkha. But it’s okay to have a sense of humor about it. May you hold your dukkha with a little levity. :)

Categories
Discourse Practice

Wise Communication, An Exploratory Practice

Greetings, Friendlies! I was recently (re)introduced to a little practice in the vast sphere of Wise Communication (sammā-vācā) maybe worth sharing: If wise communication involves an openness, a willingness to hear and to understand, then the exercise is to notice the times when I am not able to do that. When I close off, when […]

Categories
Discourse Meta Practice

Dharma PhD (the podcast) Episode 9: Everything is Included in Dhamma Practice

Transcript for Episode 9 of Dharma PhD (the podcast); we talk about bringing a dhammic lens to the zombie apocalypse (ie, HBO’s TV Series, _The Last of Us_).

Categories
Discourse

Dhamma and AI Filmmaking: A Call for Mitta

On the hunt for dhammic video editing mitta; apply here!

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

“On Reading the Suttas”, Marc Akincano Weber

Akincano is sharing his essay “On Reading the Suttas”. Dharma PhD approved!

Categories
DharmaPhD Discourse

Consolatory Physics

Perspective, Acceptance, Forgiveness, Gratitude. Thanks, science.

Categories
Discourse Scholarship Teaching

MN 139, Part 5: Subhūti

Maybe it’s not really about Subhūti?

Categories
Discourse Practice Scholarship

MN 139, Part 4: On Political Discourse

Continuing to unpack MN 139, On Avoiding Conflict (Parts 1, 2, 3)… recently Ajahn Nisabho gave a bonzer talk, Culture War Pacifism: The Dhamma of Dolly Parton. He spoke about engaging skillfully in political discourse, about not being caught up in the collective papañca of the culture wars. Might this bit in MN 139, about […]

Categories
Discourse Practice

Ajahn Nisabho, Culture War Pacifism: The Dhamma of Dolly Parton, 2023-04-15

There is a role for political discussion, for talking to people about what is meaningful. There is a role for political action and taking action. But when one is determining when and how to do that, it’s very important to understand that as practitioners of this path, you have stepped into a higher order narrative, […]

Categories
Discourse Scholarship Teaching

Unpleasant Vedanā and Hangry Bacteria?

Bridging anthropocentricity, one bacteria-laden blog post at a time.

Categories
Discourse Practice

Metta To Their Chair

Heard this in a bonzer talk a few days ago. This is it, isn’t it? It’s about, if you’re a closed sort of person, it’s about how do we open up more? Even if I can’t open up to the person, I can open up _in the direction of_ the person. And just that little […]

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

MN 139, Part 3: Safety of the Other

MN 139, on avoiding conflict, could be divided into three themes: cultivating oneself, communicating with others, and seeking out good influences in one’s life. I didn’t catch this at first, but now I see in this second theme, Communicating With Others, Gotama encouraging us to speak in such a way that we allow our interlocutors […]

Categories
Discourse Meta Scholarship

Thinking about Awakening, Part 2: All the Words

Greeting, Friendlies! Part of the tangle of ideas I spoke about in Part 1 comes from reading or hearing teachers or practitioners* use words in contexts such that I think they are referring to a territory near(ish) to Awakening. In this post I’d like to acknowledge these words and ask the hivemind what others might […]

Categories
Discourse

Thinking about Awakening, Part 1: Biases

I’ve been thinking a lot about Awakening. What is it? How does one get there? What does one “get” from it? Why do I want whatever it is? Are these even the right kinds of questions to be asking?

Categories
Discourse

Within Yourself

Happy Birthday, Marvin.

Categories
Discourse

The Eleventh Pāramī

During an Insight Dialogue Online session this week, the lovely Susie Clarion quoted someone saying A Sense of Humor might make a nice eleventh pāramī. I vote for Levity. :) PS: If you’re not doing Insight Dialogue yet, why not give it a try? PPS: In my iOS Pāli-English Dictionary, null results for both humor […]

Categories
Discourse

Incremental Backups

Because the more people coming up with silly Dhamma T-shirts, the better. :) (link)

Categories
Discourse Scholarship

Conditionality (Idappaccayatā) vs Dependent Origination (Paṭiccasamuppāda): Part 2, Conversations with Leigh Brasington

Edit: If you want to start with Part 1, that’s here. The meditation teacher Leigh Brasington wrote a book on Dependent Origination which he self published and made available for Dāna on his website. He kindly (and enthusiastically!) read my previous post on DO and Conditionality. With his permission, here’s an image we cobbled together: A few […]